Letting the spirit soar
By Richard P. Carpenter, Globe Staff
STOCKBRIDGE -- You'd probably want to visit Chesterwood and Storm King
even if they weren't among America's foremost sculpture parks. Their settings
alone -- Storm King's in the Hudson River Valley, Chesterwood's among the
rolling Berkshire hills -- merit a ramble of a couple of hours. So riveting
is their scenery, in fact, that it challenges curators to find sculpture that
can stand up to it. It's a wise curator who decides to collaborate rather than
compete with these powerful landscapes.
Bring walking shoes, bug spray and an umbrella you'll hope not to need when
visiting either park. Both demand considerable legwork. But both reward the
effort. Storm King, in Mountainville, N.Y., and Chesterwood, in Stockbridge,
are museums without walls, made up of sensitively-sited contemporary
sculpture. Just as museums place smallish works on paper in low-ceilinged,
softly lit galleries and install masterwork paintings in rooms with lofty
proportions, so outdoor sculpture can be matched to a setting. At Storm King,
that means Isamu Noguchi's ''Momo Taro,'' a stunning ensemble of nine granite
boulders, crowns a hilltop, luring the eye from far away. At Chesterwood,
George Rickey's 25-foot-tall steel ''Gyratory Cube and Square'' stands like an
alien spaceship that has landed in a vast meadow. Sometimes it's surrounded by
cows, grazing unperturbed: In addition to being a sculpture site, the meadow
is leased to a local farmer.
Chesterwood is a relic of the age when America was discovering its
artistic voice, when both the government and private citizens erected
grandiose neoclassical buildings and commissioned monumental sculptures to
adorn them. Many of those sculptures were by Daniel Chester French, best known
as the creator of the ''Minute Man'' statue in Concord and the 20-foot seated
figure of Abraham Lincoln in the Lincoln Memorial in Washington.
French worked from the Gilded Age through the Jazz Age. And from 1897 until
his death in 1931, he summered on the Berkshire property where he built a
house clad in stucco -- a material that reminded him of his beloved Italy, but
which, alas, cracks in New England winters. Chesterwood is comfortable but
hardly extravagant, especially when compared with the hundred-room Berkshire
houses deceptively dubbed ''cottages.'' The owners of those summer cottages
came calling at Chesterwood, though: They were French's patrons, and, in his
studio, in addition to the area where he worked, is a room outfitted with
Oriental carpet and grand piano where he received them. Here he entertained
in the style of Edith Wharton, offering his guests tea and lemonade.
The studio is the heart of the estate, and its cast of plaster and marble
characters includes gods, heroes, warriors and nubile maidens. Small, medium
and large versions of the same subject reveal something of French's working
methods, how the poses of those great figures evolved. Just outside the
studio's huge double doors is a short railroad track, where French would wheel
out his sculptures to see how they looked in the sunlight.
Surprisingly, the most riveting sculpture in the studio is not the cast of
the great seated Lincoln, which French worked on from 1911 to 1922, but his
1931 ''Andromeda.'' Unlike most of his works, this one was not a commission;
it was a private rather than public undertaking. It depicts the maiden of
Greek legend, nude and chained to a rock, head thrown back. The model for this
frankly erotic work was a 14-year-old local girl who earned 71 cents an hour
for the job, enjoyed regular milk and cookie breaks, and told her parents she
was working in the Chesterwood gardens.
So pervasive is French's presence in the studio that you half expect to see
him walk through the door. But Chesterwood, which French's daughter Margaret
donated to the National Trust for Historic Preservation in 1969, is more than
a museum of things past: It's also an important center for new art. Each year,
Chesterwood stages an impressive outdoor sculpture show of works scattered
through intimate woodlands and open fields. Among the highlights this year are
Tim Prentice's steel ''Wire Cats,'' strung through the trees and looking like
cobwebs; Joyce McDaniel's ''Moments of Being,'' in which fragile paper
clothing patterns, her signature material, are arranged in angles that look
like giant birds; and Susan Crowder's ''Chesterwood No. 1,'' a classical
column sheathed in tree bark, neatly merging the formality of Chesterwood's
architecture with the unruly nature that lies beyond its lawns.
You wonder, looking at these sometimes challenging contemporary works,
what French's reaction to them would have been. Even in his day he was hardly
a radical. Trained in Italy, he belonged to a movement called the ''American
Renaissance''; he thought of himself as part of a continuum. Chesterwood's
buildings and gardens reflect a love of tradition, from the wide,
Italian-style piazza wrapping around the studio to the formal geometry of a
garden bordered by curving marble benches. In that garden, the young Isadora
Duncan once danced, draped a la Greque and wreathed in flowers.
If you take the guided tour of French's home and studio, and then explore
the contemporary show, you will have spent the better part of a day. Should
you be sufficiently gung-ho to want to spend the night, you can, as of this
year. Meadowlark, a second studio French built on the outskirts of his
property when his daughter's constant entertaining became too much of a
distraction, has now been converted into a delighfully decorated two-bedroom
cottage that visitors can rent. French's sketches can still be seen on the
barnboard walls, along with fine photographs of some of his masterful
monuments. Recently, one Meadowlark guest was spied by Chesterwood staff
roaming the grounds shortly after dawn, communing with the outdoor works,
wearing a bathrobe.
The art most often associated with the landscape around Storm King is, of
course, the Hudson River School -- Thomas Cole and other mid-19th-century
painters who elevated woods and mountains to the status of American icons.
Storm King Art Center -- named for the nearby mountain that was a favorite
subject of the Hudson River artists -- has created a few icons of its own, by
such stellar sculptors as Siah Armajani, Louise Bourgeois, Sol LeWitt,
Alexander Calder, Louise Nevelson and dozens of others who make the place a
pantheon of contemporary three-dimensional art.
Storm King was once the estate of New York lawyer Vermont Hatch, who lived
in a house designed in the style of a Norman chateau until his death in 1959,
when the estate was bought by his friend and neighbor, Ralph Ogden. Ogden
turned Storm King into a regional art museum that was, well, nice. Gradually,
though, his ambitions outgrew this modest mission. Inspired by the Henry Moore
sculptures on the grounds of Sir William Keswick's sheep farm in Scotland,
and, closer to home, by the David Smith works on Smith's property in Bolton
Landing in upstate New York, Ogden decided to create a sculpture park. As a
starting point, he snapped up 13 Smith sculptures, all at once.
The Smiths became the nucleus of a collection rooted in late-20th-century
abstraction but branching out to other styles. That collection -- currently
more than 120 works by more than 100 artsts, displayed on a 400-acre site --
is uneven. The failures tend to be innocuous blobs -- rural versions of what
writer Tom Wolfe famously called ''the turd in the plaza'' because every new
office building had to have one out front.
Some of Storm King's sculpture is spectacular. Literally so in the case of
works by Mark di Suvero, who is the subject of a two-year show that gives new
meaning to the term ''blockbuster.'' Surely these multiton sculptures must
together constitute one of the weightiest exhibitions in history. Di Suvero
works in steel -- girders, I-beams, tanks, even steam shovels are incorporated
into his giant constructions that amble across the Storm King landscape. The
largest are 40 to 60 feet high, and weigh 20 tons or more. Three of them fill
a 20-acre field reshaped expressly to show them to advantage. Rerouting the
landscape so it still looks like the work of nature has become a specialty of
Storm King's longtime landscape architect, William Rutherford.
The size of the di Suveros seems ''to relate less to other sculpture than
to monuments such as the Statue of Liberty, the Gateway Arch in St. Louis, or
even the Eiffel Tower,'' writes art historian Irving Sandler, author of the
new book ''Mark di Suvero at Storm King Art Center.'' Adding to the force of
the sculptures is di Suvero's penchant for painting them in bright primaries
that stand out boldly against the backdrop of green.
It's unusual to devote such vast resources to a single sculptor. Storm King
has the freedom to do so because right along it has depended on the taste and
money of private individuals -- first Ogden, who died in 1974, then Peter
Stern, who has been the center's chairman since its founding. Thanks to them,
and to Storm King director David Collens, the center has turned itself into a
veritable di Suvero theme park.
Not that other sculptors don't make equally strong -- or even stronger --
impressions with fewer and smaller works. The David Smiths are mint, including
totem forms with a human presence that dance against the sky and gleaming
stainless steel still-lifes whose burnished surfaces seem to dissolve in the
strong sunlight. Being outdoors gives these pieces a chance to breathe and
expand that couldn't be matched in an indoor setting.
Sol LeWitt's minimalist, rigidly geometric works are jolting when seen
outside, their precision a contradiction of nature's vagaries. The LeWitt at
Storm King, the 1970 white steel ''Five Modular Units,'' merges with the grass
by casting rhythmic shadows on it. David von Schlegell's trio of steel
squares, on the other hand, seems to float above the lawns like a mirage,
courtesy of exceedingly thin, virtually invisible legs. Robert Grosvenor's
black, Cor-ten steel ''Untitled'' is more than 200 feet long, a low curve that
calmly embraces the Earth instead of soaring above it, as so many works here
do.
It's a measure of the high regard the international sculpture community has
for Storm King, and also an indication of how few venues there are for the
immense works contemporary sculptors like to produce, that Magdalena
Abakanowicz has given her 143-foot-long ''Sarcophagi in Glass Houses'' to the
center. The work of the Polish-born artist has been shaped by the political
turmoil of Eastern Europe, and usually has a figurative presence: Often, the
figures are incomplete, or uncomfortably bent. In the ''Sarcophagi,'' the
figurative element comes from an unlikely source: wooden models used to cast
19th- and early 20th-century engines. Abakanowicz has reworked the forms so
they bulge like bellies, suggesting birth, and she's housed them in steel and
glass structures that suggest transparent coffins, a la Snow White. Of all the
works at Storm King, this is the most emotionally potent.
And of all the works at Storm King, Menashe Kadishman's ''Suspended'' is
the most likely to stop you in your tracks. A huge steel rectangle plants one
point in the grass and leans sideways at an alarming angle, another rectangle
suspended from its top. The balancing act looks impossible; surely the
sculpture should fall over. Intellectually, people know that it won't, that
somewhere underground there's some powerful armature that keeps the piece
erect. Still, people do tend to keep their distance. On the day of my visit, I
saw not a single soul walk under it.
Published 09/15/96 in the Boston Suday Globe's Travel Section.