It's time to pass the sword
ew Hampshire, so tiny, so unrepresentative of America, yet so critical in determining which boring white man shall lead us all, has once again lowered its sword of Damocles.
From this point on, the rest of the states, far larger and far more representative of the modern United States, play only segmented roles. If New Hampshire wielded a sword last night, the rest of the states hold pocket knives. For a more true democracy, the sword must be passed to another state.
In an America that means what it says about diversity, this should be the last time New Hampshire holds the first primary. New Hampshire is beautiful, with lots of beautiful people. But for the sake of picking a president, it is too antiseptic.
In New Hampshire, the candidates debated only a fraction of our pressing issues. That is a natural consequence in a state that is 98 percent white and has the nation's lowest level of poverty and eighth-highest percentage of college graduates. Such bliss made it comfortable for the candidates to ignore public schools, wealth gaps, the working poor, urban blight, immigration, AIDS, sports stadiums, and - oh, yes - race relations.
The first primary should have the personal touch of New Hampshire. But it does not have to be New Hampshire. It's not like they travel in covered wagons any more. You could split the first two primaries between the highest voting state as a civic reward (which actually is Maine) and a large, diverse state such as California, Texas, Florida, New York, or Ohio.
As it is now, Iowa and New Hampshire, less than 1 percent of the American people, cook the meal the remaining 99 percent must eat. That might be fine if everyone at the dinner table looked like Ward and June Cleaver. But America is now a banquet hall with tables filled with Garcias and Wongs, with tables filled with people who send their children to terrible public schools, with tables filled with people with social and economic anxieties despite the boom.
Candidates who can digest and address the full plate of America would surely be more dynamic than the white bread we have now. Until we find a way to let a state that is representative of America have first crack at the cutting board, democracy has not been served. Until the sword is passed to them, New Hampshire represents a tyranny of the minority.
Derrick Z. Jackson is a Globe columnist.
|